Bagpipe/Practice Chanter Tuning

by Mark
(New Orleans, LA, US)

Question

Could you comment on the tuning of the scale as it differs from a modern western major scale in that the 4th, to our western ears, sounds sharp.
(Your site seems an invaluable resource.)

Thank You.

Bill's Reply

Yes, Mark, the 4th “D” is said to be slightly sharper, as is the “F”. According to research on our scale some good years ago it is the interval between “C” and “D”, and “E” and “F” that is slightly different (sharper “D” and “F”) to the nearest equivalent tempered scale.

Even then, some notable pipers of note in the recent past and a few today played/play with a slightly sharper ?D? and ?F? than we have in most good pipers? sound of today. The main reason for the slight difference on these two notes is obviously that the sound we desire of these notes has to blend well with properly set and tuned drones ? harmonics. Sadly many novices and others with little experience etc., tend to play with these two notes and some others too sharp especially on the upper hand notes by sinking the setting of the chanter reed too far in the chanter, or not adjusting with suitable amount of tape on the offending note holes. I trust this answers your question.

Regards ? and Happy New Year,
Bill